Home Up Contents FAQ Search

SZ Effect
Back Up Next

 

Community
International
Site Testing
Science Goals
Instrument Design
Budget & Schedule

Sunyaev-Zel'dovich (SZ) effect in known clusters

As CMB photons travel from the surface of last scattering to the observer, secondary anisotropies can arise due to the interaction of the CMB photons with intervening matter. Of particular interest is the S-Z effect, which occurs when CMB photons travel through a cluster of galaxies. Approximately 10% of the total mass of rich clusters of galaxies is in the form of hot (~ 108 K ) ionized plasma. Compton scattering of CMB photons by electrons in this intra-cluster plasma can result in an optical depth as high as 0.02, resulting in a distortion of the CMB spectrum at the mK level. There are multiple components of the S-Z effect which result from distinct velocity components of the scattering electrons. The thermal component is due to the thermal (random) velocities of the scattering electrons. The kinematic component is due to the bulk velocity of the intra-cluster gas with respect to the rest frame of the CMB. The spectral distortions produced by components of the S-Z effect are shown here.


Spectra of the Components of the S-Z Effect (from J. Peterson). The Rayleigh-Jeans Temperature vs. frequency of different components of the Sunyaev-Zel'dovich effect is plotted for a typical cluster of galaxies. In this simulation, the gas has temperature T= 10 keV; peculiar velocity v = 1000  km s-1 toward us; and a Thompson optical depth of t = 0.01. Solid curves indicate increments in the CMB temperature, and the dashed curves decrements. These different components can be distinguished by spectral shape using sufficiently sensitive millimeter- and submillimeter-wave detectors. From top to bottom the components are 

  1.  the classical thermal S-Z effect ( t T)
  2.  the classical kinetic S-Z effect (t v)
  3.  relativistic corrections to (1) (t T2)
  4.  thermal corrections to (2) (vt T);
  5.  finite optical depth corrections (t 2T2)

By measuring the amplitude of (1) and (3), and T may be separately determined; the amplitude of (2) additionally gives v, although measurements of this amplitude will be convolved with superposed primary CMB anisotropy, which has the same signature. This uncertainty can be removed by measuring the amplitude of (4). Accurate arcminute-resolution maps at a variety of millimeter and submillimeter wavelengths would provide information about the internal density, temperature, and velocity structure of cluster gas throughout the Hubble volume. 

The thermal component of the S-Z effect can be used in combination with X-ray data to provide a measure of the Hubble constant (H0). In addition, when combined with a measurement of electron temperature, the ratio of the kinematic and thermal component amplitudes provides a direct measurement of the cluster's peculiar velocity relative to the rest frame of the CMB. The observed surface brightness difference of both the thermal and kinematic components is independent of the cluster redshift, as long as the cluster is resolved. Clusters are large objects, typically of order 1 Mpc, and subtend an arcminute or more at any redshift, so all clusters will be resolved with the SPST. Using the SPST, accurate S-Z measurements can be made throughout the Universe, all the way back to the epoch of formation of the hot intra-cluster gas. In the last few years, high signal-to-noise detections and images have been made of the thermal S-Z effect toward several distant clusters (z > 0.15). Most of these observations have been made at centimeter wavelengths; however, observations at 2 mm by Holzapfel and collaborators have also been successful. So far, there has not been any detection of the kinematic S-Z effect. Only recently has a system sensitive enough to measure the small kinematic signal been built. The SuZIE instrument on the CSO has set a limit of vr = +170+815-630 km s-1 for the peculiar velocity of the rich cluster Abell 1689. While this experiment represents a considerable step forward, the results on Mauna Kea have been limited by sky noise. The sky noise at 218 GHz on Mauna Kea was 7 times higher than the SuZIE instrumental noise. The low noise environment of the South Pole will result in an order-of-magnitude improvement for this experiment. In addition, the wide field design of the proposed telescope will allow these clusters to be imaged, not just detected. Sunyaev-Zel'dovich effect blank-sky survey. The fast survey capability of the SPST will allow detection of S-Z effect in blank-sky searches; the SPST is highly optimized for such work. 

 

SZ Effect in Blank-Sky Fields

Detections of small-scale decrements in CMB intensity not associated with known clusters may have been discovered by Ryle Telescope and VLA observations. These may be due to the S-Z effect in very distant clusters.  Serendipitous detection of distant clusters will necessarily occur in studies of arcminute-scale CMB primary anisotropy. Holder and Carlstrom point out that these detections, both with and without additional X-ray data, allow powerful tests of cosmological models and galaxy formation theories. In particular, the cluster counts are sensitive to and provide an independent check of the type Ia supernova results. 

S-Z effect also results from low density, warm baryonic gas between clusters. Models of structure formation predict that most of the baryonic matter in the Universe is located in intra-cluster filaments which are responsible for the forest seen in quasar spectra. The S-Z effect caused by the filaments can be directly imaged by the SPST, permitting study of the filaments in the spaces between quasars.

 

 

Send mail to help@cfa.harvard.edu with questions or comments about this web site.
Last modified: April 22, 2000